December can be considered one of two things. To some, it’s the holiday shopping season. To many others, it’s that time of year that shines a particular blinding spotlight on the procrastinators of the world.
Let’s face it — gifting is hard. And the pressure to find the perfect gift for all those special people in your life can often be more than we can bear. Gift cards are always an option, but I’ve long abandoned those for being too impersonal. There are endless gift guides out there for one of a billion specific niches (like our gift guide for sports card collectors or the best holiday-themed books for kids), and individual mega-retailers like Amazon, Walmart, and Costco provide last-minute gift guides for every budget, but the recommendations are fairly random, and we’d prefer to not have to send gifts to loved ones in a Costco box, amiright?
One always-welcome gift in my household is good food. Something that has fairly consistently been on my holiday wish list every single year has been mail order meat. In my book, nothing tops a box of mail order meat in that cooler-style packaging with the dry ice.
And this got me thinking. If there are so many gift guides for all of the various hobbies and interests and niches out there (there are no shortages of pickleballing gift guides, for example), why shouldn’t there be a gift guide for people who like receiving meat from their local delivery person? So with no further ado, here is (my) ultimate gift guide for mail order meat.
Please note that we use affiliate links for things we love, so click on our links and show your support!
Mail Order Steaks
You can’t go wrong with mail order meat, and bonus points if your gift includes a half a dozen or more steaks. Whether you’re a seasoned carnivore or someone looking to surprise a meat-loving friend, just say yes to steaks.
Omaha Steaks Ultimate Gift Package
Elevate your culinary experience with Omaha Steaks’ Ultimate Gift Package, a feast for the senses that brings together a delectable assortment of premium cuts and gourmet delights. Indulge in the rich flavor of 4 Butcher’s Cut Top Sirloins (6 oz. each), expertly crafted for a succulent dining experience. Savor the luxury of 4 PureGround Filet Mignon Burgers (6 oz. each), showcasing the finest filet mignon for a burger like no other. Delight in the tenderness of Triple-Trimmed Tenderloin Tips (1 lb. pkg.) and the juiciness of 4 Air-Chilled Boneless Chicken Breasts (5 oz. each). Experience comfort with 4 Chicken Fried Steaks (4.5 oz. each), and savor the smoky goodness of 4 Gourmet Jumbo Franks (3 oz. each). Accompany your meal with the richness of 4 Potatoes au Gratin (2.8 oz. each), and end on a sweet note with 4 Caramel Apple Tartlets (4 oz. each). Additionally, 4 Individual Baguettes with Garlic Butter (3 oz. each) and a jar of Omaha Steaks Seasoning (3.1 oz.) are included to complete this ultimate gourmet package. Unleash the culinary maestro in you or surprise someone special with this exceptional assortment that promises an unforgettable dining adventure.
Grumpy Butcher Premium Steaks Set
Indulge in the Carnivor Premium Steaks Gift Set, featuring the Grumpy Butcher Premium Steaks Set that ensures a superb dining experience with every bite. This comprehensive pack includes a selection of the most popular steak varieties, ranging from the succulent Ribeye (3 pack, 14 oz each) and NY Strip steaks (4 pack, 10 oz each) to the tender Filet Mignon (2 pack, 8 oz each). Ideal for any occasion, elevate your dining moments by impressing guests or treating yourself to the pinnacle of steak enjoyment. Each steak in this set is meticulously crafted through Aged to Perfection Expert Cut and Trim techniques, promising a symphony of complex flavors, tender textures, and abundant marbling. The Grumpy Butcher NY Strip steaks (each 10 oz) are extra trimmed from the coveted short loin, while the Ribeye steaks (each 14 oz) boast cuts from the primal rib section. The Filet Mignon (each 8 oz) is a carefully chosen and expertly cut gem from the prized beef tenderloin, ensuring a premium dining experience.
Texas Roadhouse Butcher Shop
Indulge in the exquisite flavor and premium quality of the Texas Roadhouse Butcher Shop’s ribeye steaks package. Each 16 oz. USDA Choice Boneless Ribeye Steak is meticulously hand-cut to ensure a perfect balance of tenderness and rich marbling. Aged to perfection, these steaks promise a dining experience that transcends the ordinary. Sealed individually to preserve freshness, your steaks will arrive meticulously packaged in a Styrofoam cooler, complemented by dry ice to maintain their optimal temperature during delivery. From the first savory bite to the last, savor the juiciness and robust flavor that defines a true culinary masterpiece. Elevate your dining experience with these exceptional ribeye steaks that reflect the commitment to quality synonymous with Texas Roadhouse.
Feed The Pantry New York Strip Steaks
Savor the exceptional taste of the Feed The Pantry New York Strip Steaks package, featuring 8 oz USDA Choice New York Strip Cut Steaks individually sealed to lock in the freshness. The commitment to quality is evident in every aspect, from custom packaging with dry ice/gel packs to ensure your steaks arrive perfectly chilled right at your doorstep. These steaks embody the true essence of American beef, as they are 100% born and raised in the USA, with no solutions or additives—just pure, flavorful beef. Hand-cut in Louisville, Kentucky since 1946, each steak is a testament to decades of expertise, offering a dining experience that combines tradition with the highest standards of quality. Elevate your culinary journey with these premium New York Strip Steaks, a delicious and wholesome choice for those seeking the best in taste and provenance.
H.F.’s Outstanding Black Angus Beef T-Bone Steak
H.F.’s Outstanding T-Bone Steaks are said to redefine the steak experience with their rich flavor and firm, melt-in-your-mouth texture. The T-Bone cut, characterized by a substantial strip and tender filet separated by the bone, introduces an additional layer of savory depth to the already outstanding taste. These steaks are not only a feast for the senses but also an epitome of simplicity in preparation. Whether you choose to marinate and throw them on the grill for that perfect smoky flavor or prefer the ease of pan-searing, crafting a delicious steak dinner has never been easier. H.F.’s T-Bone Steaks embody the perfect balance of taste and texture, promising a culinary journey that is both indulgent and effortlessly satisfying.
Mail Order Seafood
Where there’s mail order turf, there’s mail order surf. Discover the perfect last-minute gift idea with mail order seafood, a delightful option that brings the ocean’s bounty straight to your doorstep. Elevate gift-giving with the freshness and variety of premium seafood selections that can be conveniently ordered with just a few clicks. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking to surprise someone with a unique and gourmet present, mail order seafood offers a delicious departure from the ordinary. From succulent lobster tails and plump shrimp to the finest cuts of salmon and more, this thoughtful gift ensures a culinary adventure that resonates with freshness and flavor. Say goodbye to the stress of last-minute shopping and hello to the joy of giving a gift that captures the essence of the sea, promising a memorable and delicious experience for seafood enthusiasts and culinary connoisseurs alike.
Phillips Signature Crab Cakes
For the crab lover in your life, hook up Phillips Signature Crab Cakes, available in a convenient case of 12 at 3.25 ounces each. Crafted in the authentic Maryland-style, these delectable crab cakes are a testament to tradition, combining the finest jumbo lump and special grades of crab meat. Originally formulated by Shirley Phillips, co-founder of Phillips Seafood Restaurants, in 1956, this timeless recipe is still faithfully used by all our restaurant chefs today. Enjoy the ease of no-prep time; these crab cakes can be pan-sauteed or fried straight from the freezer. Boasting a generous 70% blue swimming crab meat, this classic blend of jumbo and special crab meat, combined with a traditional base, ensures a genuine Maryland-style experience. Flash-frozen for freshness, these crab cakes can be baked directly from frozen or thawed for convenience. Their rich flavor pairs wonderfully with various sauces and condiments, making them a versatile and satisfying culinary choice.
Maine Cold Water Lobster Tails
Elevate your holiday gifting with the epitome of indulgence – the Grand Daddy of Lobster Tails. These exceptional tails, sourced from the icy waters off the coast of Maine, offer a gourmet experience perfect for any occasion, whether it’s a laid-back backyard barbecue or an elegant candlelight dinner. Each Maine Cold Water Lobster Tail, weighing 6-7 ounces, boasts firm, succulent meat with a delicately sweet flavor that will leave taste buds yearning for more. Gift the joy of premium seafood to your loved ones and make this holiday season one to remember with this exquisite selection of six lobster tails from All Fresh Seafood.
Alaskan Wild Caught Halibut Filets
Indulge in the unparalleled taste of Wild-Caught Halibut Fillets brought to you by Today Gourmet Foods of NC. Flash-frozen at the peak of freshness, these Alaskan gems ensure an exquisite dining experience in the comfort of your own home. Each fillet is individually vacuum-sealed, preserving its pristine quality and allowing for easy portioning. Shipped with utmost care in a cooler packed with dry ice and/or gel packs, the halibut fillets arrive at your doorstep ready to elevate your culinary creations. Embrace the rich, flaky texture and delicate flavor of Alaskan wild-caught halibut, a premium addition to any seafood lover’s palate. Trust Today Gourmet Foods of NC to deliver excellence in taste and freshness, making every meal a memorable and delightful experience.
Florida Royal Red Shrimp
Try the unparalleled excellence of Florida Royal mail-order red jumbo shrimp, ensuring the finest dining experience delivered right to your doorstep. When it comes to shrimp, this offering stands out as the absolute best – a flavorful treat that rivals the freshness of those straight from the Gulf. For those of us who reside far from the coastal charm, this mail-order option becomes the ultimate choice, bringing the essence of the Gulf to your kitchen. Featuring Wild-Caught Gulf Reds, exquisite Florida Shrimp, and the highly sought-after Royal Reds, this 6-pound package of headless shell-on IQF shrimp promises convenience without compromising on quality. Elevate your culinary repertoire with the best in shrimp, ensuring every bite is a delightful celebration of freshness and flavor, regardless of your distance from the Gulf.
Mail Order Bacon, Sausage, Etc.
Tired of giving gifts that end up collecting dust or mysteriously disappear into the black hole of forgotten presents? Fear not, for mail order meat is here to rescue you from the perils of uninspired gifting! It’s the present that truly keeps on giving—because who doesn’t love the aromatic surprise of fresh bacon or sausage arriving at their doorstep? Forget the usual suspects like socks or scented candles; nothing says “I care” quite like a delicious package of meaty delights. Just picture the joy on your friend’s face as they unveil the savory goodness, realizing that your gift is not just a one-time thrill but a carnivorous journey of endless delight. It’s time to embrace the philosophy that in the world of gifting, bacon and sausage are the real MVPs—the gifts that keep the hunger pangs at bay and the smiles on faces.
Pederson’s Farms Hickory Smoked Bacon
You absolutely can’t go wrong with bacon. Pederson’s Farms hickory smoked bacon is plain and simple. Making bacon without artificial nitrates or nitrites is usually a challenge, especially without sugar. But Pederson’s Natural Farms managed to do it. If you want to try it, here’s your chance. This bacon is AIP diet friendly, Whole 30, and fits into Paleo and Keto lifestyles. It’s minimally processed, with seasonings soaked in over time, not injected all at once. The pork is smoked with all-natural hickory chips and perfectly sliced. The animals get a good life, free from growth stimulants or antibiotics. No MSG, gluten, or lactose here. It’s all-natural uncured bacon, and if there’s a better way to make bacon, we haven’t found it yet.
Gourmet Variety Specialty Sausage Sampler
One of the most popular Wisconsin Sausage Gift Sampleers around, the Gourmet Variety Specialty Sausage Sampler is a delightful surprise for your cheese and sausage enthusiast friend or relative. Whether you’re attending a family picnic or looking for a thoughtful gift to show someone you care, this basket has it all to please guests. Explore the finest selections from Wisconsin’s Best features 100% Natural Cheese, Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese, Gourmet Cheeses, Aged Cheddar Cheese, Naturally Smoked Summer Sausage, Beef Sticks, Beef Jerky, and more. Our Gift Box Assortments are ideal for snacks, and appetizers, and make perfect Christmas and holiday gifts.
Ultimate Meat and Cheese Gift Crate
Delight in sending a fully loaded crate for an unforgettable charcuterie night experience with a California Delicious Ultimate Meat and Cheese Gift Crate. A delectable assortment awaits, featuring summer sausage and salami harmonizing with a savory array of cheeses and mustard. Enjoy the satisfying crunch of two types of crackers and nuts, while a drizzle of vinegar and olive oil opens up a world of delicious flavor combinations. Concluding the evening on a sweet note, indulge in the delightful addition of dried fruits. This curated crate promises a symphony of tastes that will elevate any charcuterie gathering to a memorable feast.
Give the Gift of Meat
This holiday season, let’s unwrap the gift of gastronomic joy because, let’s face it, meat is the unsung hero of holiday cheer! Picture the excitement as you present a perfectly marbled steak, sizzling on the grill like a culinary masterpiece. Or how about the luxury of crab cakes, bringing a taste of coastal elegance to your festive spread? And who could resist the allure of lobster tails, a surefire way to turn any holiday dinner into a gourmet celebration? But wait, there’s more! Imagine the delight of succulent shrimp, the crispy temptation of bacon, and the savory embrace of sausage — each a flavorful surprise waiting to grace your holiday table. From grillside revelry to cozy family dinners, this year, make your holidays sizzle with the gift of mouthwatering meat. Because, really, what says Happy Holidays better than a plateful of festive feasting?
Got a favorite mail order meat? Let’s hear about it! Drop us a note or connect with us on Facebook, Instagram, or TikTok. Happy holidays!