Looking for unique stocking stuffers for the man in your life? Look no further! Etsy is home to some of the most creative and unique gifts for men out there. From handmade watches to custom-made jewelry, you’re sure to find something special that will put a smile on his face this Christmas. In this gift guide, we’ll take a look at some of our favorite unique stocking stuffers for men on Etsy.
Here at Matty Wax, we love making handmade cards out of trading cards. We absolutely love creative gifts and want to help folks find awesome gifts from amazing Etsy sellers. So if you’re looking for something different to stuff those stockings this year, be sure to check out these amazing and unique stocking stuffers for men!
If you like what you see, please follow our affiliate links and support Etsy sellers everywhere!
Unique Sports Card Greeting Card
Of course we’re going to start with shameless self-promotion! What better way to show your man or any other sports fan in your life how much you appreciate how much he appreciates sports than with a holiday card made from real sports cards? These Unique Sports Card Greeting Cards are available in pretty much every sport — baseball, basketball, football, hockey, soccer, golf, racing, MMA, and wrestling — and can be customized with your very own personalization or simply blank inside. No two greeting cards are the same! For specialized orders, if you have specific players or cards in mind, reach out to the Etsy seller!
DIY Crossbow Kit
For the man who has everything except a miniature crossbow, this Do-It-Yourself Crossbow Kit offers twice the fun! First, he’ll need to put it together, which he can do with or without the instructions (without, of course, because who needs instructions?). Once the mini crossbow is assembled, he can enjoy it for a lifetime by shooting the included wooden animal targets. There’s a squirrel, a duck, and a rabbit that he can hunt all day — at work or from the comfort of his own man cave.
Custom Dinner Decision-Maker dice
As far as unique stocking stuffers for men go, here’s one that has likely never been stuffed in your man’s stocking. This fun Custom Dinner Decision Maker wooden die is perfect for all of those indecisive nights when you go round and round in circles trying to decide what to have for dinner. So go ahead and roll the die and let fate decide!
Customize your own with Chinese, Sushi, Italian, Fast Food, Steakhouse, BBQ, Korean BBQ, Food Truck, Burgers, Pho, Pizzeria, Subs, Seafood, Pizza, Italian, Indian, Mexican, Hibachi, Thai, Mediterranean — or reach out to the Etsy seller and design your dinner decision maker dice from scratch!
Liquor Infused Toothpicks
Aged in premium spirits, these Liquor Infused Toothpicks may be just what Dr. Santa ordered for those long holiday nights. These “Liquor Pickers” come 25 picks to a pack for a long shelf life and full-spirit freshness. Try the “all-flavor pack” to sample all of the flavors, offered and get five pickers in each pack.
Custom Bobblehead
Here we have a handmade, Custom Bobblehead created from a photo that you provide. A great little stocking stuffer for the man (or men) in your life, each bobblehead can be customized with hair, eyes, and skin. Simply place your order, submit your photo, and they’ll take care of the rest! After the figure’s head is completed, you will be sent a photo of the bobblehead for approval.
Beard Comb
For the bearded man in your life, consider this beautifully crafted, Custom Beard Comb. Offered in two types of woods — sandalwood (the darker tone) and Amoora wood (a more reddish tone),
these exceptional combs far outperform traditional plastic combs, providing ease and comfort with every beard stroke. And the best part about wood? No static! Add this unique stocking stuffer for men to your holiday list today!
Shower Beer Holder
This item speaks for itself. When you need a cold, frosty beverage while taking a hot, steamy shower, let these Shower Beer Holders hold it for you. Simply remove the double-sided tape from the back and stick it to the wall. It holds up to 7 pounds, so your beer is plenty safe. Choose from two colors (black and blue) and reach out to the seller for any custom options you’d like included.
Flag End Customizable Leather Cord Keeper
This Flag End Customizable Leather Cord Keeper should seriously be included in every man’s stocking this Christmas. Everyone needs a custom cord organizer for desk storage that can keep his office space in order and his cords from getting all tangled. Give the gift of organization this year for under $15.
Small Taproom Set
If your man loves to unwind with a good beer, then this unique stocking stuffer is perfect for him. This unique Small Taproom Set includes everything he needs to enjoy his favorite brews at home. While this may not exactly fit in your man’s stocking, it’ll certainly put a smile on his face.
The Small Taproom Set includes four glasses perfect for tasting any type of beer, and the Personalized Whiskey Barrel, which makes a great gift for any whiskey lover. So be sure to check out all of the great options on Etsy today!
Dark Brown Leather Keychain
What better way to show your guy your love this Christmas than to remind him that he should keep his keys in one place? So pick up a simple yet timeless Dark Brown Leather Keychain made in brown full-grain leather with your choice of brass or silver-colored metal hardware. Nicely embossed with the Kingsley Leather Lion, the leather strip is 18 millimeters wide by approximately 80 millimeters long. The edges have been burnished to seal the fibers, and it looks even better in person!
Multi Color Polka Dot Inlay Maple Wall Mounted Magnetic Knife Holder
Men need knives. And knives need places to be kept, preferably out of the way of our fingers and hands. This Multi Color Polka Dot Inlay Maple Wall Mounted Magnetic Knife Holder might just be the perfect unique stocking stuffer for men. Featured in a unique Yayoi design, this wall-mounted magnetic knife holder is constructed from ethically sourced wood, and unlike typical knife holders, these are made with wood so as not to scratch or dull the blades while in use. Neodymium magnets are inlaid below the surface to keep knives in place. Pick one up for your guy today!
Fish Shaped Cutting and Serving Board
Men love to fish, and men love to eat fish. And other things. So why not pick up a Fish Shaped Cutting and Serving Board so your man can serve charcuterie the way it was meant to be served? Seriously, though, this makes a perfectly unique stocking stuffer for men. Made from a sturdy hardwood Yellow Birch, each one is given rounded edges, a hole for hanging, and a food-safe oil finish.
Personalized Leather Camera Strap
For all the photogs out there, a Personalized Leather Camera Strap might be one of the most perfect creative stocking stuffers for men. The MegaGear Top Grain Leather Shoulder Strap for SLR and DSLR cameras allows your man to safely carry his camera with style and grace while relieving the stress the camera weight induces on his shoulders. Let him shoot photographs without the worry of dropping his prized camera.
Personalized Cufflinks
These handcrafted Personalized Cufflinks make the perfect gift for that special guy in your life. Made by using fine dark brown full-grain leather, these cufflinks are hand-punched and set in a quality stainless steel setting which has been expertly machined from a single piece of stainless steel providing durability and an elegant look. Impress your man this Christmas with personalized cufflinks!
Personalized Coasters
Laser engraved mango wood and marble hexagon coasters, these Personalized Coasters come in a set of four, and shipping is included in the price. Quite frankly one of the best Christmas gift ideas for men, this beautiful set of coasters is laser engraved with your man’s last name in a beautiful script font. And best of all — they might actually fit in the stocking!
Shop Unique Stocking Stuffers for Men Today!
Here at Matty Wax, we understand how difficult it can be to come up with new and creative Christmas gift ideas for men. Whether you’re looking for a unique stocking stuffer or the perfect sports-themed greeting card, then we’ve got you covered. Check out our blog for awesome new ideas for your man. And for special requests, don’t hesitate to reach out today, and don’t forget to check out all Etsy has to offer from some of the most creative individuals on the internet!